Product Review: Esteé Lauder Sumptuous Extreme Mascara

MIRACLE PRODUCT: Esteé Lauder Sumptuous Extreme Mascara ($23.50)

THEY SAY: The wand magnifies and multiplies lashes.

WE SAY: Keep reading for reviews from Style staffers!

Pros: I literally couldn't believe my eyes. My lashes looked more defined, fuller and separated. I especially loved that they curled my stubbornly straight lashes. That was pretty amazing!
Cons: I tried the blue color. Although I saw the hue on my lashes as I applied it, no one really noticed or commented on it throughout the day. But that was OK, because it meant that it was subtle enough for work.
—Danielle D., Editorial

Pros: The mascara separated my eyelashes, made them look longer and even curled them. It's my new fave!
Cons: A bit pricey.
—Daisy B., Editorial

Pros: This mascara lengthens, curls and adds volume without over-drying or clumping. It lasts all day long without smudging. Even after I put multiple coats on—my lashes were still soft and radiant. Love this mascara!
Cons: There are none. I want one in every color.
—Liana C., Photo

Bottom Line: Make room in your makeuo bag for Esteé Lauder's Sumptuous Extreme mascara! 

Visit the Style Test Drive section to see what our discerning testers thought of other products!